Signs of Medicare Identity Theft and How to Protect Yourself

Medicare provides essential health coverage to millions of Americans, but like any system that involves personal and financial information, it’s also a target for fraud. One of the most dangerous forms of fraud is Medicare identity theft, where someone illegally uses your Medicare number or personal details to obtain medical services, file false claims, or commit other crimes that can leave you facing denied services, unexpected bills, and long-term consequences.

Many people assume identity theft only involves credit cards or bank accounts, but medical identity theft is a growing concern, especially among seniors. Scammers may use stolen Medicare numbers to bill Medicare for services you never received, access prescriptions under your name, or even alter your medical records. These fraudulent activities can impact not only your finances but also your future care if misinformation appears in your health history.

What makes Medicare identity theft especially harmful is how hard it can be to detect. Unlike credit card fraud, where a single suspicious charge might trigger an alert, fraudulent Medicare claims can go unnoticed for months. You might not even realize you’ve been a victim until you receive a bill for services you didn’t get—or worse, are denied care because someone else used up your benefits.

Fortunately, there are clear warning signs you can watch for and steps you can take to protect yourself. In this article, we’ll explain:

The most common signs that your Medicare identity may have been stolen
How scammers typically gain access to your information
What to do immediately if you suspect identity theft
Practical ways to keep your Medicare number and personal information secure

Whether you’re new to Medicare or have been enrolled for years, staying vigilant is essential. With the right knowledge and proactive habits, you can protect yourself from Medicare identity theft and keep your coverage safe.

The Most Common Signs That Your Medicare Identity May Have Been Stolen

Medicare identity theft can often go undetected for months, sometimes even longer. Unlike credit card fraud, where unauthorized charges are quickly flagged, fraudulent Medicare activity may not be noticed until benefits are denied or unusual bills start arriving. That’s why it’s crucial to recognize the signs that someone might be misusing your Medicare number or personal information.

Here are the most common red flags to watch for:

1. Unfamiliar Charges or Claims on Your Medicare Summary Notice (MSN)

Each quarter, Medicare sends out a Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) that lists all services billed under your Medicare number. If you see claims for treatments, tests, equipment, or prescriptions that you didn’t receive, it may be a sign of identity theft or fraud.

Even if the services seem minor or harmless, it’s essential to investigate anything you don’t recognize. Fraudsters often “test” a stolen Medicare number with small charges before making larger, more costly ones.

2. Bills or Statements for Services You Never Received

Receiving a bill from a healthcare provider or a medical collection agency for services or procedures you didn’t receive is another major warning sign. These may come from out-of-state facilities, unfamiliar doctors, or pharmacies you’ve never used.

Even if you’re not required to pay these bills, their presence means someone is using your identity to access care—or bill Medicare fraudulently under your name.

3. Denied Coverage or Benefits

If your Medicare benefits are unexpectedly denied—especially for services you’ve never received—it may mean someone has already used those benefits. For example, if you need a specific piece of durable medical equipment like a walker or wheelchair and Medicare tells you you’ve already received one, that’s a serious indicator that your account may be compromised.

4. Conflicting Medical Records

In some cases, you may notice errors in your medical records, such as mention of conditions you don’t have or medications you’ve never taken. This can happen when a fraudster receives care using your Medicare information, resulting in incorrect data being added to your history. These errors can affect future treatments and prescriptions, making it both a safety issue and a legal one.

5. Contact from Medicare About Services You Didn’t Request

If you receive letters, emails, or phone calls from Medicare, doctors, or medical supply companies about services or devices you didn’t request, take it seriously. These could be attempts to confirm fraudulent activity—or signs that your information has already been used.

6. Calls Offering “Free” Equipment or Services

Scammers sometimes call beneficiaries offering free braces, medical supplies, COVID-19 tests, or genetic screenings in exchange for your Medicare number. These calls are almost always fraudulent. If you gave out your number in one of these situations and begin seeing charges afterward, your identity may be compromised.

How Scammers Typically Gain Access to Your Information

Now that you know what to look out for, it’s equally important to understand how scammers get your Medicare information in the first place. They use a wide range of tactics, some surprisingly simple, to trick beneficiaries into revealing personal data or exploit weaknesses in the system.

Here are some of the most common methods:

1. Phone Scams and Impersonation

The most common method is a phone call from someone claiming to be a Medicare representative. These calls often sound convincing. Scammers may claim:

You need a new Medicare card
Your benefits will be suspended unless you verify your number
You qualify for a free medical device or service
They’re conducting a health survey on behalf of Medicare

The truth is, Medicare will never call you unsolicited to ask for personal information, confirm your Medicare number, or offer you free equipment.

These scam calls often come from spoofed numbers that look legitimate. Seniors are targeted because they are perceived as more trusting, and the scammers often use urgency to get you to act without thinking.

2. Fake Medical Providers and “Free” Offers

Some scammers pose as legitimate healthcare providers or medical supply companies. They may set up booths at health fairs, run ads on social media, or send emails offering free back braces, diabetic supplies, or COVID-19 test kits in exchange for your Medicare number.

Once they have your information, they bill Medicare for expensive services or equipment you never needed—or never received.

3. Email and Text Message Phishing

Although seniors are less likely than younger people to fall for email scams, phishing emails and texts are still a growing threat. These messages may appear to come from Medicare, a pharmacy, or a trusted healthcare provider and often contain links that lead to fake websites asking you to enter your Medicare number or other personal details.

Others may include attachments that, when opened, install malware that steals data from your computer or device.

4. Stolen Mail and Paper Documents

Some identity thieves simply go through your trash or mailbox to find Medicare statements, prescription information, or medical bills. That’s why it’s important to shred all documents containing personal or medical information and never leave them out in the open.

5. Data Breaches in Healthcare Systems

Unfortunately, not all identity theft is a result of scams. Sometimes, your information is exposed through data breaches at hospitals, clinics, or insurance providers. While these are beyond your control, being aware of breaches and monitoring your Medicare account regularly can help you spot misuse sooner.

6. Third-Party “Medicare Helpers” or Fake Agents

Some scammers pose as insurance brokers or Medicare advisors, offering to help you select a plan or file a claim. While there are many legitimate brokers, always verify credentials and never share personal information until you’re confident the person is authorized.

You can confirm someone’s status by contacting 1-800-MEDICARE or checking with your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP).

7. Friends, Family, or Caregivers Misusing Information

Sadly, Medicare identity theft can happen from within one’s own circle. A caregiver or relative with access to your documents, card, or information may misuse it to gain benefits or submit fraudulent claims. While this is harder to prevent, keeping your Medicare documents secure and monitoring your account can help you detect and address unauthorized activity.

8. Online Medical Forms or Fake Websites

If you fill out medical or insurance forms online, be sure you’re using secure, legitimate websites. Look for “https” in the URL and be wary of unsolicited links. Never enter your Medicare number on a website unless you initiated the visit and know the organization is legitimate.

Understanding how scammers work and what signs to watch for is the first step in protecting your Medicare identity. Once you spot the red flags or suspect foul play, knowing how to respond quickly and report it can help stop fraud in its tracks—and protect your future coverage and care. In the next section, we’ll explore what to do if you suspect your Medicare information has been compromised and the best steps to take to secure your personal data going forward.

What to Do Immediately If You Suspect Medicare Identity Theft

If you suspect your Medicare number has been stolen or misused, it’s critical to act quickly. Medicare fraud and identity theft can have long-term consequences for your healthcare, financial wellbeing, and even your safety. Acting immediately can limit the damage, help recover your benefits, and prevent future fraud. Here are the steps to take if you think your identity has been compromised:

1. Review Your Medicare Summary Notices (MSNs) and Explanation of Benefits (EOBs)

Start by carefully reviewing your recent Medicare Summary Notices (MSNs) or your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan. Look for:

Services or equipment you didn’t receive
Providers you’ve never visited
Dates or procedures that don’t make sense

Write down any suspicious claims, the dates of service, provider names, and the costs listed. Keeping detailed records will make it easier to report and track the fraud.

2. Contact Your Medical Provider

If a suspicious charge appears from a provider you’ve used before, contact their billing department directly. It could be an error or misfiled claim, not necessarily fraud. If they confirm the charge wasn’t a mistake and you didn’t receive the service, move on to the next steps.

3. Call Medicare Immediately

Report the suspected fraud to 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). This toll-free number is available 24/7. A representative can:

Help verify suspicious claims
Flag your account for review
Offer guidance on next steps

You can also report the fraud online through the Medicare.gov website. Click “Report Fraud” or use your MyMedicare account to check claims and make reports.

4. Contact the Office of Inspector General (OIG)

For cases of suspected fraud or identity theft involving Medicare, you can file a report with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG). You can:

Call their hotline at 1-800-HHS-TIPS (1-800-447-8477)
File a complaint online at oig.hhs.gov

Reports can be made anonymously, but providing details helps investigators resolve your case more efficiently.

5. Notify the FTC and File an Identity Theft Report

Because Medicare identity theft can often include stolen Social Security numbers or personal data, report the issue to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) at IdentityTheft.gov. The FTC will:

Help you create a recovery plan
Guide you through setting fraud alerts
Assist in resolving credit or legal issues tied to the theft

6. File a Police Report

If your identity theft is tied to financial crimes or if required by a financial institution, file a report with your local police department. This creates an official record, which can be useful if you need to dispute charges or claims later.

7. Freeze Your Credit or Set Up a Fraud Alert

If your Social Security number was part of the identity theft, contact the three major credit bureaus—Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion—to:

Place a fraud alert on your credit file (free and lasts one year)
Consider placing a credit freeze, which restricts access to your credit file

While Medicare fraud doesn’t typically involve credit, thieves who steal your information may try to open credit cards or loans in your name.

8. Replace Your Medicare Card

If your Medicare number has been compromised, ask Medicare to issue a new Medicare card with a different number. Once you receive it:

Inform all your healthcare providers of the new number
Shred your old card to prevent further misuse

You can request a new card by calling 1-800-MEDICARE or logging into your MyMedicare account.

9. Monitor Your Medicare Activity Regularly

After taking action, continue to monitor your MSNs and EOBs for any future suspicious claims. Setting up an online MyMedicare account allows you to view claims more frequently than waiting for quarterly paper notices.

Practical Ways to Keep Your Medicare Number and Personal Information Secure

Prevention is just as important as reaction. By taking a few smart precautions, you can reduce the likelihood of someone stealing or misusing your Medicare information.

1. Treat Your Medicare Card Like a Credit Card

Your Medicare number is a unique identifier that can be used to commit fraud. Don’t carry your Medicare card in your wallet unless you have a medical appointment. If it’s lost or stolen, it can be used immediately to file false claims.

Store your card in a secure location and bring it only when needed.

2. Never Share Your Medicare Number Over the Phone

Unless you initiated the call and are speaking to a verified provider or Medicare representative, never give out your Medicare number over the phone. Scammers often pose as Medicare agents and use urgency or fear tactics to pressure you.

Medicare will never call you uninvited to ask for personal or billing information.

3. Be Cautious of “Free” Medical Offers

Scammers lure seniors in by offering “free” back braces, orthotics, COVID-19 tests, or genetic screenings. These offers are often used to steal your Medicare number.

If something sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Always ask for the company’s name, website, and Medicare supplier number—and then verify it independently before sharing any information.

4. Shred All Documents with Personal Information

Old MSNs, prescription labels, hospital bills, and insurance paperwork can contain sensitive data. Before throwing anything away, shred it thoroughly.

Also, avoid leaving mail with Medicare information in unsecured mailboxes for extended periods.

5. Use a MyMedicare Account

Creating a MyMedicare.gov account allows you to:

Monitor your claims in real time
Detect unusual billing faster than waiting for mailed summaries
Report issues directly online

This digital access adds a layer of visibility and control over your Medicare activity.

6. Secure Your Online Accounts

If you access Medicare or insurance information online, make sure your passwords are strong and unique. Use a password manager if needed, and enable two-factor authentication whenever available.

Avoid accessing personal or financial information over public Wi-Fi, and be cautious of phishing emails that appear to be from Medicare or your provider.

7. Be Aware of Who Has Access to Your Information

Caregivers and family members often help with medical decisions, but make sure only trusted individuals have access to your Medicare card and paperwork. Consider limiting or documenting access if you’re concerned about potential misuse.

8. Stay Educated and Informed

Scams evolve constantly. Stay informed by following Medicare updates, reading newsletters from your local Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP), or attending community presentations on fraud prevention.

The more informed you are, the better equipped you’ll be to recognize scams and protect your identity.

9. Report Suspicious Activity—Even If You’re Not Sure

If something feels off—whether it’s a call, a charge, or a provider request—trust your instincts. It’s always better to report suspicious behavior and be wrong than to ignore it and become a victim.

Call 1-800-MEDICARE, reach out to your SMP, or report fraud online through Medicare or the Office of Inspector General.

Staying proactive and aware is your best defense against Medicare identity theft. With the right habits and a plan of action, you can protect your benefits, your health, and your peace of mind.

Make sure to check out this marketplace for healthcare product reviews!